Message #16680

[Heba E. Husseyn]

These loose-cannons sound lame as always.  They really need to act their age, not their shoe size.  Such an argument is yet another example of not only lying against the Prophet (pbuh) but also defaming him by alluding that he never explained the reasons for his out-of-the-ordinary deeds, as if the Prophet (pbuh) didn't care if his actions appeared to violate the Quran and thus mislead people through his deeds.  If the Prophet (pbuh) was unwell while fasting and felt he needed to discontinue his fast, he would MOST DEFINITELY first and foremost mention the problem.  NO question of ordering the companion to bring barley water without clarifying the reason, otherwise there would be a risk that the companion might presume it's okay to break the fast while the sun is still shinning and convey the same to the community so that it becomes a practice. 

The  asinine talk of these hadithers is not worth the time it utilizes.  Please send them the link of our "Analyzing specific hadith narrations" board and ask those buggers where is the damn inside scoop or the backstory for every hadith they claim?  Reading a hadith is enough pain in the a**.  Additionally, if  hadithers' try to make a song & dance about it and expect the  readers to presume and construct a backdrop for every senseless hadith, that's stretching the madness a bit too far.