Message #9454

[Heba E. Husseyn]

Thanks my dear sister.  This was a very, very refreshing read.  The conditions for reading the Quran are really important to keep in mind prior to starting the study of the Noble Quran.  In fact, most misunderstandings and misinterpretations are the result of the pre-conditioned minds of readers.  The ahl-Hadith read the Quran keeping in mind every law and story of the Hadith and then they try to expound the Quranic verses according to the contents of the various Hadith narrations.  That's why the explanations of the ahl-Hadith are always wrong.  A lot of tafsir writers base their explanations on the false stories of people like Tabari and Ibn Kathir.  May Allah grant guidance to such folks.

The Hadith imperfections are also very correctly exposed here in this post. 

I think I know who the brother is who wrote this on Yahoo! Q&A.  I've read a few pieces written by him there too.  His name is Muhammad K.  He is a  Quran alone follower and realizes all deviations of Hadith.  So far I've found him very genuine and his writings contain very correct contents.

Thanks again sis, for the compilation of this post.  I request everyone to read it and send around please.