Message #16754

[N. Truth Seeker]

Yes, I’m acquainted with this story though not the details.  Thank you for that sisters.  The forgery is indeed appalling.  I concur it's apparently quite a recent manipulation to support the gritty modern politics involving the traitors of the Ummah who are no different from pre-Islamic Meccans.

False narrations and tales like these are meant to convey the impression that the Prophet (pbuh) wasn’t averse to making deals with the kuffar nor was it too important for him to clean the Kaa’ba of the idols.  May those responsible for preparing the blueprint of such a lie perish in Hellfire.  Ameen.

Moreover as rightly mentioned in Sister’s original post, many Meccans converted to Islam after the conquest for material or political gain, is clearly reflected in this myth itself when the hostile Usman Talha, the pagan custodian of the Kaa’ba, embraced Islam as soon as the key was returned to him.  Apparently, if the key wasn’t given to him (and in truth it wasn’t), then he would not convert  and continue his hostility until some other incentive for power and authority tempted him to become a Muslim.